Newsroom

Agencies Cannot Shield Internal Records with Attorney-Client and Attorney Work Product Privileges If the Sufficiency of a Decision-Making Process Is at Issue

Alert
11.19.2026

Agencies may be required to produce certain internal records prepared in consultation with legal counsel if such records themselves are at the core of a dispute. 

The Fair Chance Act (codified at Gov. Code, § 12952) prohibits California employers from automatically disqualifying job applicants based on their criminal conviction history. The law requires employers that intend to revoke a conditional offer based on criminal conviction history to conduct an individualized assessment of whether the applicant’s conviction history has a direct and adverse relationship with the specific duties of the position.

In Civil Rights Department v. City of Torrance, the court evaluated the Civil Rights Department’s records production request in investigating the City’s withdrawal of an applicant’s contingent job offer as a custodian due to his criminal history. The Civil Rights Department’s unlawful discrimination investigation focused on the adequacy of the City’s individualized assessments regarding the denied applicant’s prior misdemeanor convictions. The appellate court affirmed the trial court’s order to compel the City to release specific records, including templates of the individualized assessments and the written assessments themselves, prepared by or in consultation with the Assistant City Attorney. The court concluded that the City waived applicable privileges by putting the sufficiency of these assessments, and by extension, the attorney’s advice at issue, and thus rendered moot the City’s arguments that the documents reflected legal conclusions and advice, and were prepared for the purpose of informing discussions with legal counsel.

This decision does not actually clarify the scope of the attorney-client or attorney work product privileges in this context. For example, the court declined to determine whether the dominant purpose of a certain communication with agency counsel is legal in nature, or merely incidental to routine human resources or other city administrative functions.

The court did, however, emphasize that in defending the adequacy of an assessment or investigation required by law, an agency may implicitly waive crucial privileges, and thereby be compelled to produce materials previously protected from disclosure. Where an agency routinely consults counsel in internal investigations, to the extent that legal advice and ordinary staff decision-making are inextricably linked, records or contents of communications with the attorney may be vulnerable to disclosure. In the wake of this decision, agencies should not assume that an internal communication is privileged simply because an attorney is included. To avoid a similar challenge, an agency must carefully distinguish between non-privileged internal investigation documents and privileged communications in seeking to avoid a broad waiver of any claim to the privileges.

If you have any questions about potential waiver of the attorney-client or attorney work product privileges, or records requests for documents prepared in routine consultations with your agency counsel, please contact Natalie Kalbakian, or your RWG attorney.

Print PDF

Attorneys

Photo for Agencies Cannot Shield Internal Records with Attorney-Client and Attorney Work Product Privileges If the Sufficiency of a Decision-Making Process Is at Issue
{Logo Image}

Richards, Watson & Gershon delivers practical advice and solutions tailored to the unique needs of public entities. Working seamlessly across offices in Los Angeles, San Francisco, Orange County, Temecula, the Central Coast, and Sacramento, our dedicated team of experts provides the full scope of public law services.

Read More

Helpful links

Client Alerts

RWG consistently monitors developments that impact our private and public agency clients. Our frequent e-alerts serve to provide our unique insights into these developments.